Consider an avalanche of boulders tumbling down a hill interacting with each other, and changing trajectories. With just one less boulder, the avalanche would have been different. Just as a volcanic eruption can alter topography, blot out the sun, create an island, or bring death to its surroundings, so can humans impact the world around them. We would never think of an erupting volcano as impotent, yet most modern people understand that volcanic activity is fully determined by factors that cause it to behave exactly as it does; the actual cause for a volcanic eruption is a trajectory of events stretching back to the beginning of our planet and possibly, even to the beginning of the universe.
That a volcano’s behavior is not determined by factors that are disconnected from a series of causes in no way diminishes that the volcano is a source of tremendous power. The impact of a volcanic eruption is not at all diminished by being the outcome of a fully caused set of determinants. Yet the volcanic mountain is only the proximate cause of the eruption, closest to the phenomenon we associate it with. Knowing the proximate cause of something has value, yet there are limits to the degree that such knowledge has practical application.
Imagine an accumulation of ice at a curve on a highway causing cars to skid out of control and careen into one another a thousand yards down the road. While knowing exactly whose car hit whom may be legally important, until the more fundamental determinant of the icy accumulation is adequately remedied, the collision pileup will continue. Understanding how our determinants cause us to think and behave does not make us powerless, it enables an effective understanding of the factors which make us who we are, making substantive change possible.
