Getting Past the Fear

When people are fearful they are likely to behave in desperate ways.  Ratings driven local news broadcasts, the ubiquity of TV crime dramas, murder mystery novels, true crime podcasts, and manipulative political leaders in combination with social media platforms designed to emotionally engage us, all contribute to heightening public fear and anxiety about being victimized by crime.  Good leaders could help guide the public towards better decisions but unfortunately, good leaders are in short supply.  Far from leading the public toward safer and more humane policies, many exploitive politicians exaggerate the threat of crime and proudly tout that they are far “tougher” on crime than their opponents.

When we as individuals encounter predators or other individuals who threaten us our fear response prepares us for “fight or flight” – this is critical for our survival.   Modern social dynamics however are far more complex and nuanced than a one on one encounter.  Effectively dealing with those who harm others is a complicated social problem which can’t be solved with a reflexive fear-based response.  But with so many triggers in our media and in our political system avoiding a reactive fear-based response is difficult.  Critical thinking skills can make a decisive difference, helping us sort through all of the erroneous information with which we are barraged.

Naturalistic Humanism supports an experimental mindset in which critical thinking skills are a vital component.  To recognize information as accurate we need to determine if the sources of the information are reputable and authoritative.  Instead of just giving credence to provocative information we need to ask several key questions including: How would this argument look from another perspective? Who is the target audience?  What have the authors promoted and with whom have they been affiliated?  Are essential facts missing?   Is this message attacking any individual or group?  Are there other sources for this information? 

Applying critical thinking to gain a more rational grasp of the issues around public safety and criminal justice can help us make changes to our system of criminal justice that are desperately needed, but to fully get there we’ll also need to reign in our anger and moral outrage.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top